?

Log in

The Ev debate team!
 
[Most Recent Entries] [Calendar View] [Friends]

Below are the 3 most recent journal entries recorded in The Evanescence debate team!'s LiveJournal:

Wednesday, April 13th, 2005
5:12 pm
[brankani]
Topic #3

Which do you prefer - pre-Fallen style or the Fallen style?
(Sorry for bad wording...)

The focus of this topic is whether you prefer the stuff before Fallen, or as it is now. I know that we haven't yet heard the new album, so cannot quite make a sound judgement, but please, venture your opinions.

(Old albums to inspire your answer)

Evanescence EP
Sound Asleep EP
Whisper EP
Origin
The Demos
The so called 'Mystery EP' (in passing has anyone managed to get hold of this? If so, what is it like?)

I need to start doing this too...

Mod's opinion

In my opinion, I much prefer the old style of Evanescence. I love the use of the organ and piano, and the lyrics seem to have a much deeper meaning than those of Fallen. Don't get me wrong, Fallen was in fact the album that got me into the band and love the lyrics displayed there, but the lyrics seem stronger before. I also feel that the lyrics are stronger in the first version of Whisper, which is the slower version and Amy's voice sounds a lot stretched, as in the Evanescence EP version of Where Will You Go.

I am very much anticipating the release of the new album, and seeing what new ideas they have come up with. I just hope that this new 'darker' outlook Amy has promised certainly lives up to this, as I love Origin, and its much darker feel. I hope this all makes sense!

Bag (mod)
Sunday, April 10th, 2005
1:24 pm
[brankani]
Topic #2
Due to the success of the last thread, I thought I'd start a new one as people seem to start getting bored of the last topic.

Since his departure, do you feel that Evanescence have changed for better or worse without Ben? Do you prefer the new line up? How do you think this will affect the new album without his contribution, since he has been on all of the others until now?

Bag (mod)
Saturday, April 9th, 2005
12:19 pm
[brankani]
Welcome to ev_debate! Sorry for lack of nice layout etc, I have NO idea how to actually do a decent layout so if any of you nice people would contribute one, I would be much obliged :)

New members - please refer to the user info before posting. Thank you!

And now, the topic for debate.

After watching the Anywhere But Home DVD, do you feel that Amy Lee is self-centred? Discuss. (eww I made it sound like an exam question)

Points to think about...

- Her constant drinking
- Is she a good role model to younger girls?
- Is she the person you thought she was?

Have a go!
Evanescence home page   About LiveJournal.com